Deviled Potatoes: How to Make the #1 Best Recipe

Name: Deviled Potatoes That Are Better Than Baked
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 12 min
Total time: 22 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 12 baby potatoes; 4 hard-boiled eggs; 3 tbsp mayonnaise; 1 tsp yellow mustard; 1 tsp white vinegar; 1/4 tsp smoked paprika; Salt and pepper to taste; 1 tbsp chopped chives; 2 tbsp cooked turkey crumbles (optional)

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Deviled potatoes are everything you love about deviled eggs, but with a heartier, comforting twist. If you’ve been searching for a quick appetizer or snack that’s bursting with flavor, these deviled-potatoes are it. Inspired by the classic deviled egg potato salad, this recipe combines creamy yolk filling and tender potatoes in the most satisfying way.

Deviled potatoes with creamy filling and chive garnish — Deviled potatoes served fresh with tangy filling and toppings

Whether you’re making deviled egg potato salad for a picnic or prepping bite-sized deviled potatoes for a party tray, these flavorful bites deliver every time. They’re rich, smooth, and perfect for anyone who loves traditional deviled potato salad but wants something more fun to serve.

What’s great about deviled-potatoes is how easy they are to customize. Want more zing? Add mustard. Need a smoky note? Try smoked paprika or swap in turkey crumbles instead of bacon. This deviled egg potato salad recipe works warm or chilled, making it the ultimate make-ahead dish.

With the same creamy tang as devilled egg potato salad, this dish is just as satisfying as lower carb potato recipes and just as creative as TikTok egg boil hacks. Deviled-potatoes deserve a permanent place on your snack rotation.

Table of Contents

How Deviled Potatoes Became My Go-To Snack

I still remember the first time I swapped deviled eggs for deviled-potatoes. It was a Sunday potluck, and I wanted something easy to make that still had the rich flavor of my favorite deviled egg potato salad. Deviled-potatoes were the answer. They’ve got all the creamy tang of devilled egg potato salad, but with a warm, fluffy potato base that makes every bite more filling and more fun.

In my Italian-American home, deviled egg potato salad showed up at every gathering. But these deviled potatoes stole the spotlight the minute I served them. They combine the flavor of a deviled egg potato salad recipe with the soft texture of baby potatoes. Whether you like your deviled potato salad cold or your deviled potatoes warm from the oven, the flavor is always bold, zesty, and satisfying.

Filling deviled potatoes with creamy yolk mix — Deviled potatoes being filled with yolk-based creamy mixture

I’ve made these for brunch spreads, BBQs, and even as a fun twist on traditional appetizers. They’re crowd-pleasers every time. Best of all, you don’t need complicated tools or fancy ingredients. If you can boil potatoes and mix a few things in a bowl, you can make deviled-potatoes.

I like topping mine with a pinch of smoked paprika and finely chopped turkey instead of bacon. You can also go fresh with chopped chives or dill for a lighter twist. And if you’re into creative sides like accordion potatoes or potato chip mashed potatoes, you’re going to love how fun and easy deviled-potatoes are to prep.

Deviled-potatoes aren’t just a side dish. They’re the perfect upgrade to your deviled egg potato salad cravings, bringing creamy filling and tender potatoes together in a way that’s simple, tasty, and worth repeating.

How to Make Deviled Potatoes with Bold Flavor

Simple Steps for Deviled Potatoes That Impress

Making deviled potatoes is as easy as boiling eggs or prepping a deviled egg potato salad. Start by boiling small potatoes until fork-tender. Let them cool slightly, then slice each in half. Scoop a small circle from the center of each and save that fluffy bit for the filling. The filling is the key to that classic deviled egg potato salad taste. Mix egg yolks with mayo, mustard, vinegar, and seasoning until creamy. Spoon or pipe it into the hollowed potato halves for that signature deviled look.

This easy deviled potatoes recipe keeps the flavor rich and the texture smooth. For added kick, mix in chopped pickles or a little hot sauce. And if you’re serving deviled egg potato salad too, this is a great complement. The contrast of soft potato and zesty filling is just as crave-worthy as mason jar pasta salad, but with a classic twist.

Toppings That Take Deviled Potatoes to the Next Level

Deviled potatoes love toppings. Sprinkle with smoked paprika, chopped fresh herbs, or a bit of crumbled turkey. That gives them a deviled egg potato salad vibe without using bacon. You can even add a few sliced green olives or red pepper flakes if you want a bold finish. These toppings bring out the deviled flavor and give a nice visual pop too.

Printable recipe card for deviled potatoes — Printable deviled egg potato salad recipe card

If you’re a fan of picnic favorites like frog eye salad, you’ll see how these deviled potatoes fit right in. They’re ideal for outdoor spreads and potlucks, and they hold their shape beautifully. Whether you serve them warm or chilled, this deviled egg potato salad recipe in potato form is sure to please.

Deviled Potato Salad and Easy Variations

Deviled Egg Potato Salad for Every Occasion

If you love deviled potatoes, you’ll definitely enjoy deviled egg potato salad. It takes the same creamy filling used in deviled potatoes and blends it with cubed potatoes for a bold, flavorful salad. This deviled potato salad is perfect for BBQs, lunches, and quick dinners. You just boil the potatoes, dice them, and mix them with hard-boiled eggs, mayo, mustard, and seasoning. The taste is rich, smooth, and full of deviled flavor in every bite.

Just like deviled potatoes, this deviled egg potato salad recipe can be served chilled or at room temperature. For a lighter twist, use Greek yogurt instead of all mayo. If you want a smoky touch, chopped turkey works great as a mix-in or topping. It adds that familiar bite without the heaviness of bacon.

Smart Swaps for Your Devilled Egg Potato Salad

Want to change it up? Add celery for crunch or a spoonful of pickle relish for extra tang. Some people like a touch of honey mustard for sweetness, while others go bold with chili flakes. The beauty of deviled egg potato salad is that it’s endlessly adaptable. You can even use sweet potatoes for a slightly sweet, nutrient-rich twist.

This devilled egg potato salad tastes amazing next to grilled dishes or wrapped up in lettuce cups. And if you like smart meal prep options, it keeps well in the fridge. It’s as simple as vegetable egg roll filling and just as satisfying. Whether you’re into classic deviled potatoes or creamy deviled potato salad, this version lets you enjoy both in one dish.

Tips and Tricks for Perfect Deviled Potatoes

Why Soaking Potatoes Matters for Deviled Egg Potato Salad

If you’re making deviled egg potato salad or deviled potatoes, don’t skip the soaking step. Soaking cubed potatoes in cold water helps remove excess starch. This makes the texture smoother and prevents mushiness. Whether you’re prepping a creamy deviled egg potato salad recipe or roasting for deviled potatoes, soaking keeps the potatoes firm but tender.

After soaking, rinse well and boil until just fork-tender. That’s the key to deviled potato salad that holds up on a plate and deviled potatoes that don’t fall apart. It’s a simple move with a big flavor payoff.

Make-Ahead Tips for Deviled Egg Potato Salad and Potatoes

Deviled egg potato salad and deviled potatoes are both perfect for prepping ahead. You can boil the potatoes, mix the filling, and store them separately. When you’re ready to serve, just assemble and garnish. That keeps the deviled flavor fresh and the texture ideal.

Want more flavor in your deviled potatoes? Let the filling chill for at least 30 minutes. The seasoning blends deeper, just like in grecian chicken bowls, where resting time boosts the final taste.

Toppings matter too. Stick with chopped turkey, paprika, or fresh herbs. Skip any heavy toppings and keep it light but flavorful. Whether you’re making classic deviled egg potato salad or serving warm deviled potatoes, these tricks guarantee consistent results.

For a picnic or meal prep, pack these with other staples like lower carb potato dishes. It’s a tasty way to enjoy deviled potatoes with balance. Keep it simple, keep it bold, and keep the deviled egg potato salad flavor alive.

FAQs About Deviled Potatoes and Deviled Egg Potato Salad

What is a deviled potato?

A deviled potato is a small potato halved and filled with a creamy egg yolk mixture, just like deviled eggs. Deviled potatoes combine the rich flavor of deviled egg potato salad with the texture of soft baby potatoes. They are easy to prepare and perfect for parties or snacks.

Why are funeral potatoes called funeral potatoes?

Funeral potatoes are a creamy, cheesy potato casserole often served at post-funeral gatherings. While different from deviled potatoes or deviled egg potato salad, they share a comfort food vibe. Both dishes are popular at large events and easy to make in big batches.

Why are they called deviled?

The term “deviled” refers to spicy or tangy food, usually with mustard or pepper. Deviled egg potato salad and deviled potatoes use mustard, vinegar, or paprika, which give them that classic deviled flavor. The word dates back to the 1700s and simply describes bold seasoning.

What does soaking cubed potatoes do?

Soaking cubed potatoes in cold water before boiling helps remove starch. This prevents gummy texture and helps both deviled potatoes and deviled egg potato salad stay firm. It improves the final taste and makes every bite smooth and creamy, not sticky.

Whether you’re prepping a deviled egg potato salad recipe or crisping up mini deviled potatoes, these small steps improve your results. For more smart tips, check out recipes like potato chip mashed potatoes or vegetable egg rolls to pair with your next deviled dish.

Conclusion: Deviled Potatoes Are the Ultimate Snack Upgrade

Deviled potatoes bring bold flavor and creamy texture together in one easy recipe. They take all the best parts of deviled egg potato salad and pack them into tender little potato bites. Whether you’re prepping for a party or meal prepping for the week, deviled potatoes fit into any plan.

This recipe delivers the same satisfaction as classic deviled egg potato salad, but in a portable, fun-to-eat version. With just a few ingredients and a little prep, you get a dish that’s both familiar and exciting. Try them with turkey crumbles, paprika, or chopped chives for easy toppings that add color and taste.

You can also enjoy the same flavors in deviled egg potato salad. Make both for variety or pick one that fits your mood. Just like with accordion potatoes or mason jar pasta salad, these deviled options are perfect for sharing and saving.

With deviled egg potato salad and deviled potatoes on the table, you’ve got flavor, ease, and comfort in every bite.